Maternity professionals face pressure to continuously record fetal heartbeats, leading to interventions that prioritise monitoring over women’s birth priorities. Evidence suggests that uninterrupted heart rate tracing does not improve neonatal outcomes and can increase complications. The focus should be on overall fetal wellbeing rather than solely on heart rate data accuracy.
The design of the very first RCT about CTG monitoring is interesting, and it raised a question which we really haven’t ever answered fully. Does the use of CTGs create the very problem they are meant to prevent?
Women planning a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) often seek to avoid negative experiences with CTG monitoring. This new mini-course offers reliable information on fetal monitoring options during VBAC, cutting risks down to realistic size, and providing communication strategies with care providers.
Today’s post reflects on a 1959 trial concerning “fetal distress”. It highlights findings that meconium was a critical indicator of poor outcomes, while abnormal fetal heart rates weren’t reliably predictive. Should we be reevaluating current obsessions with CTG use and focusing on alternative clinical markers?
Informed consent is a critical principle in healthcare. A recent Australian survey revealed that many women lacked sufficient information and choice about fetal monitoring methods. Only 35% reported being asked for consent. This highlights a significant issue in maternity care, and it is well past time it was addressed.
Today’s post shares the back story behind our paper. #CTG #EFM #PerinatalMortality #CP
@TransformingMCC
@ProfJennyGamble
@MarySidebotham
@GriffithMidwifery
This is the third post in a series I am writing about the Auscultated Acceleration Test or AAT. If you haven’t been following along and don’t know what this test is – you can read about it here. The goal of antenatal CTG monitoring is to predict which fetuses are at risk of a poor outcome relating to low oxygen levels, so action can be taken and therefore avoid death […]
Last week I explained what the AAT was. This week I want to share research that compared one midwife against another, to see if they were able to generate an accurate assessment of the fetal heart rate pattern, and were able to detect accelerations as reliably as a CTG machine. If you missed last week’s post and don’t know what I’m talking about – you can find it here. How […]
With thanks to Maryann Long, CNM, PhD, for bringing Lisa Paine’s work to my attention. I’m always fascinated about how some new ideas “stick” and are incorporated into practice, while others fall by the wayside. Despite having read widely about fetal heart rate monitoring options for the past decade, the Auscultated Acceleration Test never crossed my path. This simple approach seems to have fallen by the wayside. I want to […]
Birth Small Talk 