Nonsense-based CTG use

A German study criticised the use of antenatal cardiotocographs (CTGs) for low-risk women, highlighting a disconnect between clinical practice and evidence. This is nonsense-based care and it hides a HUGE human rights abuse.

A German study criticised the use of antenatal cardiotocographs (CTGs) for low-risk women, highlighting a disconnect between clinical practice and evidence. This is nonsense-based care and it hides a HUGE human rights abuse.

A study by Roth et al. (2026) examined signal loss in external cardiotocography (CTG) during labor, revealing significant gaps in heart rate recordings. Findings indicated no clear correlation between these gaps and adverse outcomes for babies, challenging common beliefs about continuous monitoring.

There are some major limitations of continuous CTG monitoring during labour. Recent studies exploring fetal heart rate and contraction patterns fail to identify patterns that reliably predict problems. Maybe we need to stop and head in a different direction altogether…

A new study examined neurological outcomes in children born via caesarean section due to non-reassuring fetal monitoring. They found no differences in the rates of neurological problems when compared with caesarean done for non-progressive labour. The authors conclusions implied one possible reason for this – but there are other ways to interpret these results.

In 2023, Australia recorded 218,099 births, with a rising cesarean section rate, now exceeding 40%. Induction rates and maternal age increased, while the perinatal mortality rate also rose to 11.0 per 1,000. Despite efforts to enhance birth safety, outcomes show concerning trends, necessitating reconsideration of the high rates of intervention.

A recent Australian study investigated women’s experiences with various fetal monitoring methods during labor, finding that wired CTG was predominant. First-time mothers reported more CTG use, which correlated with higher emergency cesarean rates and epidural use. Many women felt monitoring negatively impacted their experiences, highlighting a need for improved woman-centered maternity care practices.

CTG monitoring during vaginal birth after caesarean section (VBAC) is often deemed essential, but evidence suggests it does not prevent uterine rupture. Abnormal fetal heart rate patterns indicating rupture can also occur for other reasons. Therefore, CTG is not mandatory; women should choose their monitoring method based on individual circumstances.

Women planning a vaginal birth after cesarean (VBAC) often seek to avoid negative experiences with CTG monitoring. This new mini-course offers reliable information on fetal monitoring options during VBAC, cutting risks down to realistic size, and providing communication strategies with care providers.

Does CTG misinterpretation harm babies? Or is something else going on?
Have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.